Return of the Secaucus Seven
|
ABOUT THE PRODUCTIONAs Sayles wrote in his book Thinking in Pictures: The Making of the Movie
Matewan, "In 1977 I wrote a novel called Union Dues that begins in
West Virginia coal country and moves to Boston. Before I wrote it I did
a lot of reading in labor history, especially about the coal fields, and
that was when I came across the story of the Matewan Massacre. In a book
about the Hatfield and McCoy feud in Mongo County, there was a mention
of a distant cousin of the Hatfields named Sid, chief of police of the
town of Matewan, who was involved in a bloody shoot out in 1920, during
the mine wars of the era. It got me interested, but accounts of the incident
were few and highly prejudiced. The rhetoric of both the company-controlled
newspapers of the day and their counterparts on the political left was
rich in lurid metaphor but short on eyewitness testimony. But a few characters
stuck in my head - Sid Hatfield; the mayor, Cabell Testerman, who wouldn't
be bought at a time when the coal companies routinely paid the salaries
of public officials and expected their strike-breakers to be deputized
and aid in busting the union; a man known only as Few Clothes, a giant
black miner who joined the strikers and was rumored to have fought in
the Spanish-American War; and C.E. Lively, a company spy so skilled he
was once elected president of a UMW local. Aspects and details of other
union showdowns in the area also began to accumulate - the transportations
of blacks from Alabama and European immigrants just off the boat to scab
against the strikers; the life of the coal camp and company store; the
feudal system of mine guards and "Baldwin thugs" that enforced
the near slavery the miners and their families lived in. All the elements
and principles involved seemed basic to the idea of what America has become
and what it should be. Individualism versus collectivism, the personal
and political legacy of racism, the immigrant dream and the reality that
greeted it, monopoly capitalism at its most extreme versus American populism
at its most violent, plus a lawman with two guns strapped on walking to
the center of town to face a bunch of armed enforcers - what more could
you ask for in a story? And yet it was a story unknown to most Americans,
untold on film but for a silent short financed by the UMW in the aftermath
of the massacre. The movie was called Smilin' Sid and the only known print
was stolen by coal company agents and never seen again." Continues Sayles, "Though there were familiar Western elements to the story,
it had a unique character because of its setting. The hills of West Virginia,
the people and the music have a mood and rhythm to them that needs to
be seen and heard to be felt completely. There is a cyclical sense of
time there, a feeling of inescapable fate that in the story resists the
optimism and progressive collectivism of the 1920's workers movement.
Politics are always at the mercy of human nature and custom, and the coal
wars of the twenties were so personal that they make ideology accessible
in a story, make it immediate and emotional. It was this emotional immediacy
that made me think of making a movie about the events in Matewan. If storytelling
has a positive function, it's to put us in touch with other people's lives,
to help us connect and draw strength or knowledge from people we'll never
meet, to help us see beyond our own experience. The people I read about
in the history books and the people I met in the hills of Kentucky and
West Virginia had important stories to tell and I wanted to find a way
to pass them on." Matewan depicts the events surrounding the 1920 Matewan massacre, a precursor
to the 1920-21 West Virginia Mine War. The real town of Matewan proved
too remote and too modernized to serve as the actual location for the
filming but Thurmond, West Virginia was the perfect location for the movie
since even in its late-80's state, it closely resembled the 1919-1920
period needed for the movie. It was also close to the other major locations
of the film - the Beckley Exhibition Coal Mine and Grandview State Park,
site of the miners' tent camp in the film. As Sayles explains, "The cornerstone of our production design was finding
a town to serve as own main set for the town of Matewan. Once a wild river
town with big hotels, gambling and prostitution, the Thurmond we found
in 1986 was a quiet handful of buildings along the New River in one of
the state's best white-water rafting areas. The main street was really
not a street but a series of railroad tracks, with a beautiful old train
station and wheelhouse still standing and a huge cement coal dock straddling
the track at the other end of town. The population was down to around
sixty or seventy people. Hills rose up steeply just behind the single
row of buildings on the main street and from the banks of the other side
of the river, just as in the real Matewan. The buildings were almost all
brick, most built before the First World War. It had the blend of natural
beauty and industrial function we were looking for, far from the drone
of airplanes and highway traffic." "There was still an enormous amount for our production designer, Nora Chavooshian,
to do, but there was an important number of things we wouldn't need to
do - bury power lines, cover or dig up sidewalks, remove hundreds of TV
antennae, reroute highway traffic, etc. Nora kept the idea of "functional"
and "worn" throughout the production design. Nora and the director
of photography, Haskell Wexler, worked together on controlling the texture
and color of what went in front of the camera, establishing a period look
with design rather than with filters or by treating the film stock." Thurmond's history is every bit as colorful as, and in many ways parallels, that
of Matewan. The town was built by Thomas G. McKell when his wife left
him 12,500 acres of coal fields. After a ten mile branch was built to
connect the town to the railway line in the 1890's, a 100-room hotel was
built in 1901 to house the constant traffic of coal operators, businessmen,
gamblers, adventurers, whores and others flocking to the town for a piece
of the action. Thurmond hosted a 14-year continuous poker game and featured
a bar that never closed. Dead men were no novelty, in the river or elsewhere
in town. One historian wrote of Thurmond: "the only difference between
hell and Thurmond was that a river ran through Thurmond." Matewan was shot in seven weeks in the summer and fall of 1986. It was carefully
selected to be Cinecom's first wholly financed production. The film was
shot entirely on location in West Virginia and cost just under four million
dollars. Considering than this was a period film shot on location, that
was no small feat. The cast and crew were housed in the Econolodge in
Mount Hope, West Virginia, a motel whose motto was "spend a night,
not a fortune." Avy Kaufman, the location casting director for the film, arrived in West Virginia six weeks before shooting began. She met hundreds of area residents in her search for the 31 speaking roles and hundreds of extras she was to cast from local talent. "The way John writes made it easy for these people, even those with little acting experience. He seemed to know them - their speech, their personalities." A great deal of the atmosphere of Matewan comes from the authenticity of the characters and the strong sense of place the period reconstruction evokes. The West Virginians involved with the filming - actors and crew members alike - were filled with stories about the time Sayles was trying to bring to life. Kaufman saw that the personalities of those she was auditioning mirrored the inner strength Sayles had written into the characters in his script. "These people would tell such sad stories," Kaufman remembers, "but they would always pull something positive out of it - they just had a special way of doing things, honest and straightforward." That honesty is an integral part of these people and their story. It came through clearly, even in the small roles many of the locals brought to life with only a line or two. |